Literature Annotations


Sacks, Oliver
Seeing Voices


Genre Treatise
KeywordsAcculturation, Anatomy, Communication, Cross-Cultural Issues, Deafness, Disability, Disease and Health, History of Medicine, Individuality, Medical Advances, Patient Experience, Society
Summary

In this book Sacks takes the reader into the world of the prelingually deaf, a world in which spoken language is incomprehensible. He describes the visual language, Sign, and considers the development and culture of American Sign Language. Sacks evokes the conflict between those who seek to teach the deaf to communicate via voice and lip-reading and those who affirm Sign, the native culture of the deaf.

In the latter part of the book, Sacks re-creates the student rebellion at Gallaudet University in 1988 when a "hearing" president was chosen from among three finalists, two of whom were deaf. The back cover summarizes this book as "a provocative meditation on communication, biology, and culture."

CommentaryOliver Sacks is one of the great clinical writers of our time. This book covers many facets of prelingual deafness, from neuroanatomy through language development to the contemporary culture of the deaf. It is a brilliant example of the genre Sacks has termed "romantic science." In this case, he considers a whole group of people and their collective narrative, rather than utilizing individual patient narratives, as in The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat (see this database) or Awakenings (see film annotation).
PublisherHarper Perennial
Edition1989
Place PublishedNew York
Annotated by Coulehan, Jack
Date of Entry 06/24/94
Last Revised 11/30/06